Get Your Teen Magazine in your inbox! Sign Up

PSAT, Pre-ACT, PSAT 8/9: College Testing Before Tenth Grade

College Testing Overview For Early High School

By Joanna Nesbit

College admissions can feel high stakes. And we worry that our teenagers will get behind. So we feel a responsibility to give them every academic nudge as early as possible. Earlier is better, right? Going with that assumption, is earlier also better for college testing?

Relax, say college admissions testing experts. For the majority of students, there’s no need to break out the ACT or SAT study guides until the summer before junior year. Here’s what families of younger students need to know.

Sophomore Year is a Typical Time to Start.

Most schools administer the PSAT (the preliminary SAT) in fall of sophomore year as a practice test for the junior-year PSAT and SAT. The PSAT exam isn’t an admissions test. And colleges never receive the scores. The purpose is to provide SAT practice and to identify top testers who might qualify for National Merit scholarships if they take the PSAT again junior year.

A PreACT (formerly the ACT Plan) is as a sophomore-level practice test for the ACT. But only students whose schools offer the PreACT can take it because the test isn’t available to the general public. The PreACT isn’t tied to scholarship opportunities and, like the PSAT, scores are not reported.

There’s no need to prepare for the PSAT sophomore year.

According to experts, prepping in 8th or 9th grade for the PSAT is unnecessary. Even sophomores needn’t prepare, says Jed Applerouth, founder of Atlanta-based Applerouth Testing. “For the vast majority of students, prepping in 9th or 10th grade is an inefficient use of time,” Applerouth says. “We see tremendous gains when students begin prepping for the SAT or ACT after sophomore year.”

Juniors can take the PSAT again, but for most it’s not worth it.

If students score very high (typically in the top 2 percent) on the junior-year PSAT, they may earn National Merit recognition and college scholarships. It’s the only reason students should take the PSAT as juniors, explains Megan Dorsey, test prep expert and founder of the Houston-based College Prep Results. Students who score in the top 5 to 10 percent on the PSAT during sophomore year would do well to study for the junior PSAT for a chance to qualify for National Merit.

What should 8th, 9th, and 10th graders do vis-a-vis college testing?

Younger students can still work on skills that help with college testing. “The best thing is to focus on schoolwork,” says Dorsey. Take rigorous courses that help build critical thinking, problem-solving, and math skills. Read fiction and nonfiction texts from many subjects to help develop a strong college-bound vocabulary in all content areas.

SOPHOMORE YEAR: If your student does not take the PreACT sophomore year, encourage her to try a full-length practice ACT at home. Students can get free practice tests at their school’s college counselor office or online. Compare the experience with the PSAT. The tests are more similar than ever, thanks to recent changes to the PSAT/SAT, but there are still some differences: the SAT has three sections, while the ACT has four, for example.

Which test suits your student better (feels easier, less stressful, etc.)? Use the results to decide which official admissions test — the SAT or the ACT — your student will take junior year. The results can also help identify areas for improvement (math, reading comprehension, etc.). While many juniors take both the ACT and SAT, focusing on one is often more effective and less expensive. “I encourage taking each test once to see which test you perform better on,” says Cecilia Castellano, vice provost at Bowling Green State University. “Then take the better test for you a second time, because your results generally go up a little after the first sitting.”

So, when do the tests actually count?

So when’s the best time to take the SAT or ACT? Most students take their first official ACT or SAT test sometime during junior year. If your student plans to take a test fall of junior year, then he should start preparing the summer before. Allowing a month or more to prep for the junior year SAT or ACT is key whether studying independently, taking a class, or working with a tutor. Don’t cram the night before!

Wait, what about AP tests? Or SAT subject tests?

Sophomores taking AP classes are required to take the AP tests for those classes in the spring. Experts recommend these sophomores also take the corresponding SAT subject tests. Many competitive colleges require students to submit two or more subject tests, so it’s worth taking them while the material is still fresh in your student’s mind. But students can also take subject tests junior year or early senior year.

What about the PSAT 8/9 (new in 2015)?

Taking this test can be advantageous for students who are trying to get college credit for high school courses through their state’s dual enrollment program, explains Castellano. “In Ohio, for example, the College Credit Plus program allows students as young as 7th grade to take high school courses and earn college credit, provided the student can meet the same admissions requirements as a regular applicant, and an early PSAT score can be used to demonstrate that a student is qualified,” says Castellano.

Some extracurricular programs may require a college admissions score.

Most families won’t need to think about college testing before 10th grade, but some programs for academically gifted students may require that they take PSAT 8/9, SAT, or ACT to get in. Two examples: the Duke TIP program and the Johns Hopkins Center for Talented Youth. Seventh graders and older qualify with SAT/ACT scores. These highly academic programs are suitable for academically gifted children only.

Joanna Nesbit

Joanna Nesbit is a freelance writer based in the Pacific Northwest. She writes frequently about parenting and her work has appeared in The Washington Post, Family Fun, Parenting, and elsewhere.