“The goal of parenting isn’t to raise good teenagers,” says Dr. Wes Crenshaw. “But to raise good adults.”
Today, we welcome two new bloggers, Dr. Wes Crenshaw, a psychologist and longtime contributor to Your Teen, and high-school senior Kyra Haas. Together, they will be answering parent’s questions in their blog, Our Two Sense.
Why two perspectives? Well, we think Kyra puts it best, when she says: “Wes knows what works because he’s worked with teens since before your teen or I was born. I know what works because I am a teen who’s been working at life since I was born.” Enjoy.
Dear Your Teen:
What would you recommend to help me motivate my teenager to do more than sit around?
First, decide what you mean by a motivated teenager. That won’t look the same for every family. For every teenager who is, as you describe, sitting around doing nothing, there’s one who is being driven to the point of madness by scheduling too many extracurriculars, AP classes, jobs, or other calendar events.
The secret in life is to find balance. That’s as true for teens as it is for adults. It also matters whether you’re talking about motivating teenagers to say, go out for sports they don’t want to go out for (very difficult), clean rooms that they aren’t inclined to clean (fairly difficult) or do chores they don’t like (actually, pretty easy).
In figuring out how to motivate your particular teen, first determine how he or she “leans” in terms of anxiety and inattention. Most teenagers will lean one way or the other.
Anxious leaning teenagers care too much. They want to please parents and everyone else. Their solution to any problem is to try harder and do more work. Pushing them harder will raise their anxiety, which ultimately makes them less productive.
Inattentive teenagers don’t care enough. They are carefree, wait until the last minute and don’t worry about how other people view them. These teenagers need to have their anxiety raised to a productive level. They need more structure, reward, and guidance than anxious teenagers.
Assuming you’re correctly assessing your teenagers, they sound like inattentive under-doers. So, you have a couple of options and I suggest doing both. However, I’ll warn you up front, that requires you to do more than sit around. You have to follow-through day in and day out, and that’s where most parents struggle.
How to motivate your teenager
Reorganize their world so that leisure time is regulated by you
This used to be standard parenting practice, but it’s failed in recent years as telephones became personal communication computers and video games became unlimited access. That means you turn off all gadgets and Internet access until assigned tasks are completed. Then turn them on again. By the way, around here we are of the “the no-electronics in the bedroom” school of thought, making what I’m proposing infinitely easier.
Tie desired behaviors to a specific benefit, which could be cash or time online or other privileges your teenagers enjoy
I understand this is upsetting to some parents who see rewarding their teenagers as a “bribe,” but when was the last time you went to work without being “bribed?” Same here. In my home and those of my client families, we set things up so that rewards aren’t handed out freely. They’re paid in exchange for specific behavior. And guess what? Teenagers perform their tasks.
On Twitter, I often see tweet after tweet about how a friend is procrastinating instead of doing homework. Tempted as I am to smh (Twitterspeak for “shake my head”), the irony of the situation is not lost on me. I am what I read.
Social media, Xbox, texts and other digital temptations constantly vie for our attention. Those beeps and alerts are overwhelming—and exciting. Even now, I hear Twitter calling to me from across the room.
So, if as a parent, you want your teenager to do her homework or feed the cat or take out the trash, then take away her phone or Nintendo DS until the task is complete. Your teenager won’t like this, but I’ve found that the further away I am from my phone, the quicker I complete my physics homework. The same holds true for cleaning my room, reading a book or doing laundry.
The reward strategy Wes lays out is effective when the task at hand is necessary. If you don’t take out the trash, the house will reek. If your teenager doesn’t do his history homework, he’ll fail the class.
But there’s a difference between a teenager caving to his parent’s demands and actually being internally motivated to do something. You may have enjoyed basketball in high school, but pushing (bribing) your teenager to go out for varsity or play year round so you can attain some vicarious achievement won’t make your teenager a motivated basketball player. Instead, capitalize on your teenager’s interests, even if it’s not your dream pursuit.
If your teenager’s “motivation” stems only from a desire to get you to stop nagging, you can bet that the moment you’re not there, all that “motivation” will go out the window.
Wes Crenshaw, Ph.D., ABPP, is author of several books, most recently I Always Want to Be Where I’m Not: Successful Living with ADD & ADHD. Learn about his other writing, media, and practice at dr-wes.com. Kyra Haas is a Free State High School senior and Editor in Chief of the Free State Free Press.